Skip to content
Mealworms vs Black Soldier Fly Larvae For Chicken?
In recent years, there has been a growing interest in sustainable and nutritious feeding options for livestock, particularly poultry. As the demand for eco-friendly and efficient feed sources increases, the debate between Black Soldier Fly Larvae (commonly known as fly grubs) and mealworms has gained significant attention. Both types of insect larvae are celebrated for their high nutritional value and environmental benefits, making them popular choices in the animal feed industry.
Fly grubs and mealworms each bring unique advantages to the table. Fly grubs, with their impressive waste-processing capabilities, are a prime example of how insects can contribute to a circular economy by recycling organic waste into valuable nutrients. On the other hand, mealworms, known for their high protein content and adaptability, have long been a staple in animal feed and pet food sectors.
This article aims to provide a detailed comparison of Black Soldier Fly Larvae and mealworms. We will delve into various aspects of these insect larvae, including their nutritional benefits, cultivation practices, environmental impact, and overall suitability as poultry feed. By examining these factors, we hope to offer valuable insights that will help producers, farmers, and feed manufacturers make informed decisions about incorporating these insects into their feeding strategies.
Overview of Each Insect: Fly Grubs vs. Mealworms
Fly Grubs (Black Soldier Fly Larvae)
Scientific Name: Hermetia illucens
Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL) are the larvae of the Black Soldier Fly, renowned for their efficiency in waste conversion and nutrient recycling. The lifecycle of BSFL spans approximately 45-60 days from egg to adult, consisting of four distinct stages: egg, larva, pupa, and adult. The larval stage, lasting about 14-20 days, is particularly critical as it involves the consumption of substantial amounts of organic material, making the larvae highly effective in waste breakdown.
BSFL thrive under optimal breeding conditions of warm temperatures (25-30°C) and high humidity (60-70%). These conditions are crucial for their growth and reproduction. Naturally, they are found near decaying organic matter, compost, and manure, where they contribute significantly to waste breakdown and nutrient cycling.
Wiki Table type for Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL)
| Attribute | Description |
| Scientific Name | Hermetia illucens |
| Common Name | Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL) |
| Kingdom | Animalia |
| Phylum | Arthropoda |
| Class | Insecta |
| Order | Diptera |
| Family | Stratiomyidae |
| Genus | Hermetia |
| Species | H. illucens |
| Lifespan | 45-60 days (egg to adult) |
| Life Cycle | Egg → Larva → Pupa → Adult |
| Optimal Breeding Conditions | Warm temperatures (25-30°C) and high humidity (60-70%) |
| Habitat | Found near decaying organic matter, compost, manure |
| Animals That Can Eat BSFL | Chickens, ducks, fish, reptiles, pigs, pet birds, amphibians |
| Nutritional Benefits | High in protein (up to 42%), fat (up to 35%), calcium, and essential amino acids |
| Feeding Method | Can be fed live, dried, or processed into meal |
| Potential Harms and Risks | Generally safe; ensure they are sourced from uncontaminated environments to avoid disease or chemical contamination |
| Environmental Benefits | Sustainable feed option; can be produced using organic waste, reducing waste and carbon footprint |
| Other Uses | Composting organic waste, producing biofertilizer, potential for biodiesel production from larvae fat |
| Origin and Distribution | Native to the Americas, now widespread globally |
| Economic Importance | Used in waste management, animal feed production, and potential in biofuel industry |
| Digestive Enzymes | Produces enzymes that help in breaking down organic matter |
| Reproductive Behavior | Females lay eggs in clusters near decaying material |
| Growth Rate | Rapid growth; larvae can double in size within a few days |
| Conversion Efficiency | High efficiency in converting organic waste into biomass |
| Commercial Production | Cultivated on a large scale for animal feed and waste management |
| Life Cycle Stages |
Egg: Females lay clusters of 500-900 eggs near decaying organic matter. Larva: Lasts about 14-20 days, consuming large amounts of organic material. Pupa: Pupation takes about 7-10 days. Adult: Lives for about 5-8 days, primarily for reproduction. |
| Nutritional Composition |
Protein: Up to 42% Fat: Up to 35% Calcium: High levels, beneficial for egg-laying birds Amino Acids: Rich in essential amino acids |
| Safety Considerations | Ensure larvae are raised in clean, controlled environments to prevent contamination. |
Mealworms
Scientific Name: Tenebrio molitor
Mealworms, the larvae of the darkling beetle Tenebrio molitor, are commonly found in stored grains and cereals. Their lifecycle spans 6-12 months, encompassing four stages: egg, larva, pupa, and adult. During the larval stage, which lasts about 3-4 months, mealworms grow by consuming grains and other dry matter.
Mealworms thrive in cooler conditions (20-25°C) and low humidity (50-60%), which makes them relatively easy to cultivate compared to other insect larvae. They are naturally found in dry, dark environments such as stored grains, where they are highly adaptable and well-suited to these conditions.
Wiki Table type for Mealworms
| Attribute | Description |
| Scientific Name | Tenebrio molitor |
| Common Name | Mealworm |
| Kingdom | Animalia |
| Phylum | Arthropoda |
| Class | Insecta |
| Order | Coleoptera |
| Family | Tenebrionidae |
| Genus | Tenebrio |
| Species | T. molitor |
| Lifespan | 6-12 months (egg to adult) |
| Life Cycle | Egg → Larva → Pupa → Adult |
| Optimal Breeding Conditions | Warm temperatures (20-25°C) and low humidity (50-60%) |
| Habitat | Typically found in dry, dark environments, often in stored grains or cereals |
| Animals That Can Eat Mealworms | Chickens, ducks, fish, reptiles, birds, amphibians, and some mammals |
| Nutritional Benefits | High in protein (up to 25%), fat (up to 15%), fiber, and essential vitamins and minerals |
| Feeding Method | Can be fed live, dried, or processed into meal |
| Potential Harms and Risks | Generally safe; ensure they are sourced from uncontaminated environments to avoid disease or contamination |
| Environmental Benefits | Sustainable feed option; can be produced using organic waste, reducing waste and carbon footprint |
| Other Uses | Composting organic waste, used as bait, potential in animal feed and pet food |
| Origin and Distribution | Native to Europe and North America, now widely distributed globally |
| Economic Importance | Used in animal feed production, waste management, and pet food industry |
| Digestive Enzymes | Produces enzymes that aid in breaking down organic matter |
| Reproductive Behaviour | Females lay eggs in clusters within their habitat, typically in dark, enclosed spaces |
| Growth Rate | Moderate growth rate; larvae take several months to reach full size |
| Conversion Efficiency | Efficient in converting organic waste into biomass, though less efficient than some other insect larvae |
| Commercial Production | Cultivated on a large scale for animal feed, pet food, and waste management |
| Life Cycle Stages |
Egg: Laid in clusters in dark, dry environments. Larva: Lasts about 3-4 months, feeding on grains. Pupa: Takes 2-3 weeks. Adult: Lives 2-3 months, primarily for reproduction. |
| Nutritional Composition | Protein up to 25%, fat up to 15%, fiber, vitamins (e.g., B vitamins), minerals (e.g., iron, zinc) |
| Safety Considerations | Ensure proper storage and handling to prevent contamination; wash hands after handling live mealworms |
Mealworms vs. Black Soldier Fly Larvae for Chickens
Wondering what to feed your chickens? The mealworms vs. black soldier fly larvae discussion has been around for some time. Both are nutritious insect snacks loved by chickens, but understanding their differences can help you make an informed choice.
Mealworms: What & Why
Mealworms are the larvae of species of darkling beetles known as Tenebrio molitor. They are more likely to be found in the Mediterranean. Originally thought of as garden and crop pests, they are edible for various animals.
Life Cycle of Mealworms
Egg - The first stage of the lifecycle starts with eggs. The female darkling beetles lay somewhat 500 eggs into the ground after fertilisation. It usually takes around one to four weeks for an egg to hatch, and then the larva emerges from it.
Larva - The second stage of the life cycle, i.e., the brown larva, lasts about eight to ten weeks. Here the mealworm crawls and keeps growing as it vigorously eats vegetation or dead insects. The worm sheds its hard outer shell around 10 to 20 times during this stage to develop. Once the larvae transform into fully-grown worms, they are golden brown and approximately over an inch long.
Pupa - The pupa stage is the third and inactive stage, lasting from a few weeks up to a couple of months depending upon the temperature of its surroundings. This stage usually lasts for a short period of the warm surrounding temperature.
Adult - It is the last stage where the adult beetles pop out of the pupa, and then the process starts all over again.
Benefits of Mealworms
Protein: Mealworms are rich in protein, containing approximately 50%. This high protein content supports overall health and muscle development in chickens.
Fat: Mealworms have a significant fat content of 25%, providing essential energy for chickens.
Fiber: They contain about 7% fiber, which aids in digestion and promotes a healthy digestive system.
Calcium: Mealworms are notably low in calcium. Calcium is crucial for chickens' egg production and bone health, so this deficiency can be a drawback.
Health Considerations: While mealworms can enhance protein intake, they should be fed in moderation. Excessive consumption may lead to health issues such as gout or an imbalanced
Black Soldier Fly Larvae: What & Why
The black soldier fly larvae are the piranhas of the insect world. They are capable of eating a wide variety of waste and can quickly eat twice their body weight each day. They are also known as the tiniest powerhouse recyclers and are native to the Western Hemisphere and Australia. The black soldier flies do not tend to spread undesirably and do not bite or sting, making them harmless.
Like any other insect, the black soldier flies undergo a complete metamorphosis stage, starting from eggs to larvae to pupa and the adult phase. Their life cycle can last for about 45 days in the wild. However, if grown for commercial purposes, the hatch-to-harvest period can last as short as 15 days. This short hatch-to-harvest period makes black soldier fly larvae the most economical insect to raise.
Life Cycle of Black Soldier Fly Larvae
- Egg: Female Black Soldier Flies lay eggs in clusters, typically near decaying organic matter, compost, or manure. Each cluster contains approximately 500-900 eggs. The eggs hatch in about one to four days under ideal conditions.
- Larva: The larval stage lasts approximately 14-20 days. During this time, the larvae feed aggressively on organic waste, rapidly growing and increasing in size. This stage is crucial for converting waste into nutrient-rich biomass.
- Pupa: Following the larval stage, BSFL enter the pupal stage, which lasts about 7-10 days. During this phase, the larvae transform into pupae, undergoing significant changes to become adult flies.
- Adult: Adult Black Soldier Flies emerge from the pupal stage and live for about 5-8 days. The primary function of adult flies is reproduction. After mating, females lay eggs to continue the cycle, starting the process over again.
Benefits of Black Soldier Fly Larvae
BSFL contains high levels of protein (48%), fat (28%), and moderate levels of fiber (10%) and calcium (3%). This nutritional profile is beneficial for molting chickens, helping them regain feathers. The high calcium content supports strong eggshells, making BSFL a better choice for chicken feed compared to mealworms.
- Protein: Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL) contain high levels of protein, up to 48%, which is essential for molting chickens as they need extra protein to regenerate feathers.
- Fat: BSFL are rich in fat, providing up to 28% fat content. This helps in energy provision and supports overall health during periods of high protein demand.
- Calcium: The larvae have a calcium content of 3%, which is significantly higher compared to mealworms. This supports the production of strong eggshells and overall skeletal health in chickens.
- Nutritional Advantage: The combination of high protein and calcium in BSFL makes them particularly beneficial for chickens, especially during molting and for enhancing eggshell quality, making them a better feed option than mealworms.
How Do I Decide Which One Is Ideal?
Deciding whether Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL) or mealworms are the better choice for animal feed depends on various factors, including nutritional content, environmental impact, and practical considerations for feeding.
Nutritional Content
- Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL): These larvae are highly nutritious, boasting up to 42% protein and 35% fat. They are also rich in calcium and essential amino acids, making them particularly beneficial for poultry. Their high calcium content supports strong bones and healthy eggs, which is crucial for laying hens.
- Mealworms: Mealworms offer up to 25% protein and 15% fat. While they are nutritious, their calcium levels are lower compared to BSFL. Mealworms are also rich in fiber, which aids in digestion, but they may not be as effective in supporting calcium-dependent functions like eggshell formation.
Environmental Impact
- Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL): BSFL are champions of sustainability. They efficiently convert organic waste into high-quality feed, reducing landfill waste and lowering carbon footprints. Their rapid growth and ability to thrive on various organic materials make them a powerful tool in waste management.
- Mealworms: Mealworms also contribute to sustainability by processing organic waste. However, they require more controlled environments and longer periods to reach full size, which can be less efficient compared to BSFL.
Cultivation and Practical Considerations
- Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL): BSFL thrive in warm, humid conditions and have a relatively short life cycle of about 45-60 days. They are less sensitive to environmental changes compared to mealworms, making them easier to farm on a larger scale. Their quick growth rate and high conversion efficiency make them a practical choice for large-scale production.
- Mealworms: Mealworms need dry, dark environments with temperatures ranging from 20-25°C. Their life cycle is longer, taking up to 6-12 months from egg to adult. While they are less efficient in converting organic waste compared to BSFL, their easier storage and handling make them a viable option for various applications.
Lets understand the differences in the following tabular form:
| Attribute | Fly Grubs (Black Soldier Fly Larvae) | Mealworms |
| Scientific Name | Hermetia illucens | Tenebrio molitor |
| Common Name | Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL) | Mealworms |
| Lifespan | 45-60 days (egg to adult) | 6-12 months (egg to adult) |
| Life Cycle | Egg → Larva → Pupa → Adult | Egg → Larva → Pupa → Adult |
| Optimal Breeding Conditions | Warm temperatures (25-30°C) and high humidity (60-70%) | Cool temperatures (20-25°C) and low humidity (50-60%) |
| Habitat | Near decaying organic matter, compost, manure | Dry, dark environments (stored grains or cereals) |
| Nutritional Benefits | High in protein (up to 42%), fat (up to 35%), calcium, essential amino acids | High in protein (up to 25%), fat (up to 15%), fiber, essential vitamins and minerals |
| Feeding Methods | Live, dried, or processed into meal | Live, dried, or processed into meal |
| Environmental Benefits | Sustainable feed; reduces waste and carbon footprint | Sustainable feed; reduces waste and carbon footprint |
| Economic Importance | Used in waste management, animal feed production, potential in biofuel industry | Used in animal feed production, pet food industry, waste management |
| Other Uses | Composting, producing biofertilizer, potential biodiesel production | Composting, used as bait, potential in pet food |
| Growth Rate | Rapid growth; larvae can double in size within a few days | Slower growth; takes several months to reach full size |
| Reproductive Behavior | Females lay eggs in clusters near decaying material | Females lay eggs in clusters in dry, dark environments |
| Conversion Efficiency | High efficiency in converting organic waste into biomass | Less efficient compared to fly grubs in waste conversion |
| Safety Considerations | Ensure larvae are free from pesticides and contaminants; monitor for allergic reactions | Ensure larvae are free from pesticides and contaminants; monitor for allergic reactions |
| Commercial Production | Cultivated on a large scale for feed and waste management | Cultivated for animal feed, pet food, and bait |
If you prioritise high nutritional content, especially calcium for poultry, and seek an environmentally friendly option with high efficiency in waste conversion, Black Soldier Fly Larvae might be the better choice. They are also easier to cultivate and have a more significant impact on sustainability.
On the other hand, if you are looking for a more traditional option with easier handling and storage, mealworms can be a good choice. They provide essential protein and fiber but may require supplementation for calcium and other nutrients.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs, whether that’s maximising nutritional benefits, ensuring environmental sustainability, or managing practical aspects of insect farming.
Conclusion
The choice between fly grubs and mealworms for poultry feed depends on specific needs and priorities. Fly grubs offer superior calcium content, faster growth rates, and more significant environmental benefits, making them an excellent choice for chickens, especially during molting or when higher calcium is required. Mealworms, while nutritionally beneficial, lack in calcium and may need to be supplemented with other sources of this essential mineral. Considering factors like nutritional value, economic feasibility, and environmental impact will guide you to the best choice for your flock.
For those seeking high-quality black soldier fly larvae, Fly Grubs offers nutrient-dense BSFL, raised sustainably and free from contaminants. Their products provide a reliable and eco-friendly feed option for poultry, supporting overall health and productivity.
Looking for Black Soldier Fly Larvae?
Fly Grubs wants the best for your flock, their chicken feed, and supplements. If you’re searching for good-quality black soldier fly larvae for your chickens, your search ends here. Fly Grubs offers the best quality dried BSFL, a sustainable source of protein, calcium, and healthy fat for your flock. Our all-natural dried BSFl is more nutrient-dense than all the others on the market and contains 85X more calcium than mealworms.
What’s more? Fly Grubs are raised on traceable pre-consumer food waste, such as fruits, vegetables, and grains, which otherwise would go to a landfill. Furthermore, they come in a resealable bag made from recycled plastic.